Before the 2008 season, the Yanks decided to hold onto Phil Hughes and Melky Cabrera instead of trading for Minnesota’s Ace: Johan Santana. Santana ended up being traded to the New York team that plays home games in Queens for a terrible package of Philip Humber, Carlos Gomez, Deolis Guerra, and Kevin Mulvey. Santana signed an extension with the Mets that would keep him as their ace through 2013, with a $25mm club option ($5.5mm buyout) to keep him for the 2014 season. Santana went on to be exactly what the Mets wanted, posting a 2.53 ERA in ’08 with a 1.15 WHIP. He was less dominant in 25 2009 starts, but that’s attributed to his injuries, and a 3.13 ERA is still pretty damn good. Now, CC has a 2.89 ERA and a 1.21 WHIP through 25 starts for the Mets this year. But, still, how many times have the Mets reached the playoffs since getting Johan?
Some think the Yanks should’ve traded Hughes and Melky (or whatever it was that Minnesota wanted), then signed CC in the off-season to have the league’s two highest paid pitchers at the front of the rotation. Instead, the Yanks passed on Santana, missed the ’08 postseason, signed Sabathia in the offseason along with Mark Teixeira and AJ Burnett, and won the 2009 World Series. One of the key factors in the Sabathia was his team-first mentality. Okay, maybe that wasn’t a key factor. Maybe it was how he was the reason Milwaulkee made the postseason, or his 2007 Cy Young award, or his 251 K’s in 253 innings…yeah, those were key factors. But the team-first mentality was icing on top, and a nice insurance that CC would succeed in New York. Despite struggling early (as he’s done his whole career), CC pitched 230 regular season innings in ’09, while maintaining a 3.37 ERA and a 1.15 WHIP. He won the ALCS MVP award, and over his 5 playoff starts had a 1.98 ERA and 32 Ks over 36.1 IP.
I knew I liked Sabathia when I heard this story about his days in Milwaulkee: CC’s agents called up the Brewers front office asking them to stop making Sabathia pitch complete game after complete game after complete game. He was averaging over 7 and 2/3 innings per start in Milwaulkee, and threw 7 complete games for his club. His agents worried that all the wear and tear on his arm would decrease his value in the free agent market, or that he might get hurt and not be able to sign the contract he earned. CC found out about this, yelled at his agents, and told his manager that the team came first, and he wanted to be on the hill whenever he could be.
CC obviously didn’t see his contract suffer, as he signed the huge deal that brought him to the Bronx. Yesterday, he racked up his 15th win of the year and when asked about possibly reaching 20 wins said: ““I try to stay away form personal goals to be honest. I’d rather win a World Series than win 20 games and win a Cy Young.”
As spring training started in ’09, CC was seen with his new teammates at Miami Heat games. He started what amounted to a pre-game tradition through the spring, as he and all of the other starters who weren’t taking the hill that day would go and watch whoever was starting’s bullpen session. He created an incredible sense of “team” among the starting rotation, something most aces don’t do. CC handles the media with ease, is known to play Nintendo RBI baseball before his starts, and is about as big (metaphorically and physically) a part of the clubhouse as anyone that wears the pinstripes.
While CC struggles at times, he never gets down on himself or his team. He has streaks of brilliance and dominated the playoffs.
So, Johan Santana has been great for the Mets (in the National League though…). He probably would’ve pitched great in New York, but that likely would’ve meant either no CC or no Mark Teixeira for the Bronx Bombers. Those two guys were pretty big parts of that World Series team, no? Meanwhile, Phil Hughes was the game’s best 8th inning man last year, then made the all-star game as a starter this year. Also, he’s just 24. Melky Cabrera had a decent season last year, and then was part of the package that brought Javy Vazquez to the Bronx (you can debate whether or not that was a good trade at some other time). As we get further and further away from the days when we all dreamt of Johan pitching the Yanks to a championship, it becomes more and more apparent that letting Santana go to Shea Stadium (and later, CitiField), was the best decision for the Yanks. If they hadn’t, the Yanks would either be without CC or Teixeira, and they’d certainly be without Phil Hughes. Chances are, they’d also be without ring number 27.
GM’s tend to get praised or booed for the deals they do make, but it seems like one of the smartest (and toughest) decisions that Brian Cashman has made in the past five years was one that resulted in no deal, and resulted in a playoff-less year. Bravo, Brian.
